Crime + investigation
After Kidnapping His Children, Atlanta Dad Starved 4-Year-Old to Death
Rodney McWeay took his three kids from their custodial parent in July 2023. In December of that year, one was found dead.
On December 11, 2023, Atlanta police responded to Rodney McWeay’s home and found his two sons, ages 3 and 4, extremely dehydrated and malnourished. At the time, officers were at the residence due to reports of an unresponsive child. The unresponsive child report wasn’t about either boy, but their 4-year-old sister, Treasure McWeay, who cops also discovered in the house before she was pronounced dead at a hospital.
Like her brothers, Treasure was malnourished and dehydrated. Her autopsy uncovered how severe the neglect was, with the report detailing that she weighed 24 lbs. when she died.
Rodney didn’t have custody of his three children when police found them in his home in December 2023. In fact, the Georgia Division of Families and Children's Services (DFCS) removed the children from his home in June 2023, after getting a report about the children being starved in a home that reeked of mold and urine.
Monster in My Family
A riveting series that delves into the world of infamous serial killers as the family members of the killers reach out to the families of the victims.
DFCS Steps In
"The first thing that came to mind is…he’s going to kill those children,” Wanda Polnitz told Fox 5 Atlanta, recounting why she called DFCS about Rodney in June 2023.
Polnitz, a daycare operator, knew Rodney through one of her daughter’s friends. That friend reportedly signed on as the children’s live-in nanny, and she asked Polnitz to call DFCS after three nights.
DFCS investigated Polnitz’s report that the three children appeared hungry and were living in deplorable conditions and placed the children with their mother, who fled with them to Maryland amid concerns of domestic violence. The children had reportedly witnessed Rodney beat their mother and an older sibling.
“Power and control issues are involved with child neglect and domestic violence. Sometimes it’s about hurting the other parent versus really thinking about what they’re doing to the child,” Dr. Tonisha M. Pinckney tells A&E Crime + Investigation.
Ashia Hawkins, a DFCS child protection investigator, told the court how she attempted a welfare check at the home in June 2023. She said she requested backup from Atlanta police because she believed the children were locked in a room and Rodney aggressively tried to stop caseworkers from entering the residence.
During the visit, Rodney reportedly told Hawkins, "This is how I have my kids trained,” before he unlocked a door, snapped his finger and pointed to a spot on the floor where Treasure sat. Hawkins described the encounter as “animalistic” while tearfully recounting how the girl uttered indecipherable sounds to communicate.
Court documents from the visit state the children were kept separated in locked rooms with surveillance cameras facing their beds. They allegedly also had no access to bathrooms or water.
No child neglect charges were filed at the time, but the visit led DFCS to place the three children with their mother. On July 6, 2023, Rodney drove to Maryland and took the kids back to Georgia.
DFCS stated that in June 2022, the agency sought intervention through juvenile courts, but its request was denied due to insufficient evidence.
“CPS [DFCS] can't file charges. All they can really do is remove the child from the home and initiate proceedings and maybe remove the child from them permanently,” Kathleen Brown, legal director at the Hembree Bell Law Firm, tells A&E Crime + Investigation. “They can temporarily remove children and take emergency action, like a longer order. Normally, after that process, it’s figured out where they're going to place the child for safety if there's not a parent to place them with.”
‘Just Pure Bone’
Eleven days after Rodney abducted the three kids from their custodial parent, a woman who identified herself as a family friend called 911 to request a welfare check because the children’s mother didn’t know her kids’ location. Bodycam footage showed Atlanta police Sergeant Johnny Sutton stating, “There's nothing at all we can do," without a report on file.
Fulton County Deputy District Attorney Lauren McAuley listed seven instances in which Fulton County DFCS caseworkers and law enforcement tried to check on the children after the abduction, including the welfare check 11 days after the kidnapping. The final call occurred less than a month before Treasure was found dead, and Atlanta police didn’t respond to that call until nearly five hours later.
The medical examiner determined Treasure died from cardiac arrest caused by extreme malnutrition. Investigators wrote that the 4-year-old’s cheekbones and eyes were sunken in, with Det. Summer Benton describing her as “just pure bone.”
As Pinckney points out, hiding children from the public is common in abuse and neglect cases. One study found that children with substantiated maltreatment had significantly higher rates of school absenteeism.
“It's hard to control those children if there are outside influences,” she says. “You don't want someone offering support or help, so you want to keep the children isolated, with your voice as the only voice that they hear.”
Lacey Fletcher’s Parents Let Her Die, But Claimed Their Daughter, Who Had Autism, Refused Care
The non-verbal, 36-year-old with autism died in January 2022.
The non-verbal, 36-year-old with autism died in January 2022.
Rodney McWeay Stands Trial
“The proof required to take a case to criminal court and convict someone is much higher than in both family law and children's court with DFCS,” California family law attorney Thomas MacLean tells A&E Crime + Investigation. “If you had the same standard [beyond a reasonable doubt in criminal cases] to protect kids or a spouse from abuse, there'd be a lot more abuse going on because it's such a high standard. It makes sense to have a lower standard to ensure they're protected.”
On December 21, 2023, Rodney was arrested for his daughter’s death. In June 2025, he stood trial for malice murder and felony murder, in addition to first-degree cruelty to children, false imprisonment, contributing to the dependency of a minor and kidnapping. Prosecutors offered a 75-year plea deal, which he turned down.
Pediatrician Dr. Keely Iannelli told the court that the children’s development started out normal, but subsequent records showed declines in speech, weight and other developmental markers. She noted that a child had bruising consistent with physical abuse.
Iannelli also said that Rodney noticed Treasure’s breathing was labored and her hands were blue. He called 911 after putting her in a tub, and she didn’t respond to the bathwater. She also described how the 4-year-old deteriorated due to prolonged malnourishment.
“Basically, the heart is the last to go," the doctor explained.
During Rodney’s trial, a Georgia DFCS caseworker cried while testifying that Treasure’s death was “100% preventable” and that the agency had “failed” her.
The Aftermath
Jurors took less than a day to find Rodney guilty of all 14 charges: one count of malice murder and one count of felony murder; three counts of cruelty to children in the first degree; three counts of false imprisonment; three counts of contributing to the dependency of a minor; and three counts of kidnapping. On July 10, 2025, he was sentenced to life in prison plus 155 years.
In February 2025, five APD staff members were disciplined for how they responded to the McWeay home in the months leading up to Treasure’s death. Sergeant Sutton received a written reprimand for failing to investigate the welfare check request made days after the kidnapping. Other officers received written discipline or oral admonishments. APD officials didn’t publicly comment on the internal probe or the punishments handed down to the officers.
DFCS confirmed to Fox 5 Atlanta that it’s conducting an internal investigation into its handling of the case but has not publicly disclosed the outcome.
“This case is a heartbreaking reminder of what can happen when young children are cut off from safety and support,” District Attorney Fani Willis said after Rodney’s sentencing. “Treasure suffered from hunger, thirst and neglect at the hands of her father, who used violence and control to keep her and her brothers from the help they needed.”
Rodney is currently serving his life sentence at Dooly State Prison.
Close Knit Town Shattered When 11-Year-Old Girl Goes Missing on Halloween
Show: City ConfidentialIn 1992, an 11-year-old vanishes after a Halloween party, shaking her town. Police hunt for years to unmask the evil and bring justice.
Related Features:
The Harlem Park Three: How 3 Men Were Exonerated After 36 Years
Alfred Chestnut, Andrew Stewart and Ransom Watkins were convicted of DeWitt Duckett's murder.
The 1986 Wood Chipper Murder That Became Connecticut’s First No-Body Murder Conviction
Helle Crafts' husband killed her and sawed her into pieces in November 1986.
Where Are Sam Bankman-Fried and Caroline Ellison Now?
They orchestrated a billion-dollar fraud with their cryptocurrency exchange, FTX.
Police Found 8 Women’s Bodies at New York Home of Kendall Francois
Investigators called his Poughkeepsie, N.Y., home a "toxic environment."
About the author
Fact Check
We strive for accuracy and fairness. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! A&E reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it is complete and accurate.
Citation Information
- Article Title
- After Kidnapping His Children, Atlanta Dad Starved 4-Year-Old to Death
- Author
- Jacquelyn Gray
- Website Name
- A&E
- Date Accessed
- November 19, 2026
- Publisher
- A&E Television Networks
- Last Updated
- November 17, 2026
- Original Published Date
- November 17, 2026