Skip to main content

Crime + investigation

The Harlem Park Three: How 3 Men Were Exonerated After 36 Years

The 1984 murder of 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett led to the convictions of Alfred Chestnut, Andrew Stewart and Ransom Watkins. But after a witness recanted, the three men were freed.

Harlem Park Three (from left) Alfred Chestnut, Andrew Stewart and Ransom Watkins attend the 'When a Witness Recants' premiere during the 2026 Sundance Film Festival on January 27, 2026, in Park City, Utah.

Getty Images
Published: November 16, 2026Last Updated: November 16, 2026

Since 1989, the number of individuals who have been convicted of a crime and then exonerated—often decades later—is at almost 4,000, with over 36,000 collective years lost behind bars.

One notable story of a wrongful conviction in U.S. history involves the Harlem Park Three—three Baltimore teenagers who were imprisoned for a murder they did not commit in 1984, before information about police coercion and withheld evidence led to their exoneration in 2019.

American Justice

American Justice

"American Justice" explores recent compelling criminal cases, from those that made national headlines to gripping lesser-known cases, through the prism of our justice system.

DeWitt Duckett’s Murder

On November 18, 1983, 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett and two friends were walking to the cafeteria at Harlem Park Junior High School in Baltimore when they were suddenly stopped by an older teenager. He pointed a gun at the back of DeWitt’s neck and demanded the boy hand over his Georgetown University Starter jacket, a coveted item at the time. DeWitt began to remove the jacket, but when his two friends made a run for it, DeWitt was shot in the neck and died from his injuries later that afternoon.

The crime shocked the West Baltimore community, and a police investigation began. Soon, teachers revealed three rowdy 16-year-olds—Alfred Chestnut, Andrew Stewart and Ransom Watkins—had been at the school the day of DeWitt’s murder. Chestnut in particular raised police’s suspicions, as he was wearing a Georgetown Starter jacket when he was interviewed, despite his mother clarifying the family had a receipt for the item. After police corroborated with eyewitness statements, the teenagers were charged as adults with first-degree murder, armed robbery and illegal use of a weapon less than a week after DeWitt’s death.

As Chestnut later stated in a WJZ-TV interview, “We told [police] the truth from the beginning. We had nothing to worry about because we didn’t do anything, but innocence wasn't enough.” Despite maintaining their innocence during their trial in May 1984, all three were found guilty of first-degree murder, armed robbery and illegal use of a weapon after a jury deliberated for less than three hours. The teenagers were eventually sentenced to life in prison, a decision that was upheld by the Maryland Court of Special Appeals upon direct appeal.

It would take 36 years for the truth to come to light.

How Did the Harlem Park Three Get Convicted?

In the week between DeWitt’s murder and the teenagers’ arrest, Baltimore police fixated on 14-year-old Ron Bishop, the only one of DeWitt’s friends who got a good look at the assailant. He was hounded by police and even brought in for questioning and photo identification lineups without his parents’ knowledge. Watkins later said on the ACLU of Maryland’s Thinking Freely podcast that the police “made it clear, ‘I don’t need their parents’ … But you need that on the books to protect the child.”

Police eventually coerced Bishop—along with three other witnesses who hadn’t even seen the crime—to identify Chestnut, Stewart and Watkins as the killers after threatening to charge Bishop with perjury or as an accessory to murder after the fact. Despite the inconsistencies from Bishop’s original statement of there being only one assailant, in 1984 the four “eyewitnesses” testified to the three teenagers’ involvement in DeWitt’s death.

Watkins hasn’t expressed shock at the way Bishop and the other middle schoolers were intimidated by police: “The officer that arrested us told me when they first got us locked up [that] he white, I’m Black. They're going to believe what he say, regardless of what I say.”

A Witness Recants

Though a judge had sealed the police records related to DeWitt’s murder, an imprisoned Chestnut obtained them through a public records request in 2018. He learned about the misconduct, bullying of eyewitnesses and how an 18-year-old named Michael Willis was continually mentioned as a suspect but never pursued, his name withheld for decades.

With this information, Chestnut contacted the State’s Attorney’s Conviction Integrity Unit. Prosecutor Lauren Lipscomb reviewed his findings and later told Vox Media’s Criminal podcast, “[Willis] presented a conflict that was really glaring. That is what caused me to initiate a full-blown investigation.”

Bishop was soon contacted by the State’s Attorney’s Office. He actually believed Willis shot DeWitt, but Willis was killed in 2002, so he couldn’t be investigated for the crime. Willing to risk having lied under oath, Bishop recanted his statements and detailed the police coercion. The other witnesses soon followed suit.

On November 25, 2019—36 years since their arrest—Circuit Court Judge Charles Peters wiped all three men’s convictions, saying, “On behalf of the criminal justice system, and I’m sure this means very little to you gentlemen, I’m going to apologize.”

“I really don’t have the words to say. I just thank God, man, I really do,” Stewart said to WBAL-TV upon release. When asked how it felt to be out, he simply responded, “It’s surreal.”

The Harlem Park Three Are Exonerated

In August 2020, Chestnut, Stewart and Watkins sued the three detectives and the entire Baltimore police department for mishandling their case nearly four decades prior. The paperwork detailed the ways in which police strong-armed witnesses, suppressed evidence and presented a false narrative. In 2023, the lawsuit reached a $48 million settlement—the largest in Maryland’s history.

But Watkins has noted that, despite the legal victory, he doesn’t feel there’s been accountability: “In our case, you paid us off. But who actually paid for it? Our family, DeWitt Duckett['s] family and us. Everybody else walked free.”

As noted in the 2020 lawsuit, the prosecution relied on “coerc[ing] four middle schoolers into falsely implicating Alfred, Andrew and Ransom,” a fact that has haunted Bishop for decades. Ultimately, it was his decision to finally tell the truth that helped overturn the case—a sobering reality on the challenge of overturning wrongful convictions.

“If the police know that he can fabricate evidence and nothing will happen, what deter the officer from stop doing the same thing? Nothing, right?” Watkins told the ACLU of Maryland regarding police misconduct. “But if you start taking they pensions … you’re going to be held accountable for this.”

Infamous Crimes: The Amanda Knox Trial, Part 2

Alison Becker talks about Amanda Knox's trial in Italy and her ultimate exoneration.

2:11m watch

Related Features:

Police Found 8 Women’s Bodies at New York Home of Kendall Francois

Investigators called his Poughkeepsie, N.Y., home a "toxic environment."

7m read

Did a Fire Destroy Critical Evidence in the Murders of a Mom and Her Daughter?

Heather and Kira Radcliffe's December 2006 murders remain unsolved.

6m read

Jim Bakker's Christian TV Empire Fell Due to a $158 Million Fraud Scheme

He built a broadcasting dynasty but then lost it all.

4m read

How Did Annie McCann Die? 16-Year-Old’s Parents Suspect Foul Play

The state medical examiner listed the teen's manner of death as “undetermined."

8m read

About the author

Reshma Patricia Crawford

Reshma Patricia Crawford is a freelance writer and aspiring novelist whose short stories and music reviews have been published in literary magazines and on digital media platforms. She has also spent a decade working as an Associate Producer and a Development Producer on nonfiction television series for A&E, Hulu, Lifetime, National Geographic, Smithsonian Channel and Animal Planet. Reshma holds an MFA in Screenwriting from Hollins University and currently lives in Culver City, Calif.

More by Author

Fact Check

We strive for accuracy and fairness. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! A&E reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it is complete and accurate.

Citation Information

Article Title
The Harlem Park Three: How 3 Men Were Exonerated After 36 Years
Website Name
A&E
Date Accessed
November 16, 2026
Publisher
A&E Television Networks
Last Updated
November 16, 2026
Original Published Date
November 16, 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement