Crime + investigation

Can Fingerprints from 1943 Solve the Black Dahlia Murder?

An independent forensic examiner says he has the key to solving the Los Angeles murder of Elizabeth Short that's been cold for more than 80 years.

Los Angeles Times via Getty Imag
Published: August 12, 2026Last Updated: August 12, 2026

On January 15, 1947, a woman was walking in Los Angeles’ Leimert Park neighborhood when she stumbled upon a discarded mannequin in a vacant lot. As she drew closer, however, she realized it wasn’t a mannequin at all, but rather the body of a dead woman who’d been mutilated.

The discovery launched one of the largest homicide investigations in the history of the Los Angeles Police Department. However, the murder of Elizabeth Short, who became known as the “Black Dahlia,” has remained unsolved ever since. 

Now, nearly 80 years later, police are investigating newly uncovered evidence that could shed light on the gruesome crime. Marty Mojarro, a cold case investigator for the LAPD, told Fox News Digital he’s looking into a 1943 fingerprint card that purportedly bears the prints of Marvin Margolis, Short’s ex-boyfriend and an early suspect in the case. 

The card was discovered by Alex Baber, a self-taught cryptographer and independent forensic examiner who co-founded Cold Case Consultants of America. Baber believes the fingerprint card could potentially help solve several cold cases—the murder of the Black Dahlia as well as the five murders attributed to the Zodiac Killer

He’s spent the last five years looking into the unsolved mysteries and claims to have cracked the mystifying, 13-letter code the Zodiac Killer used to identify himself in an April 1970 letter to the San Francisco Chronicle. According to Baber, the so-called Z13 cipher spells out “Marvin Merrill,” one of the names Margolis used.  

Whether the fingerprint card will help advance the investigation remains to be seen. But investigators working on the Black Dahlia case welcome any and all potential leads because, after nearly eight decades, they “don't have live witnesses to interview," Mojarro told Fox News Digital. 

“This is probably one of the most difficult cases [to solve], realistically, because of the time that’s passed," he added.

Who Was the Black Dahlia?

The Black Dahlia is the nickname given to Elizabeth Short, a 22-year-old aspiring actress found dead in 1947. She was discovered naked, with her body cut in half at the waist and drained of blood. Short’s corpse was covered in deep cuts, and a “Glasgow smile” had been sliced ear-to-ear across her cheeks. 

Based on the lack of blood found at the scene, police determined she’d been killed elsewhere, then moved. Her body had been butchered with surgical precision, leading investigators to believe her killer likely worked in medicine.

The case created a media circus with reporters playing up the crime and sullying Short’s reputation with unfounded rumors about her lifestyle and dating habits, Kevin Hale, a retired police chief who now serves as chair of the criminal justice program at Post University, tells A&E Crime + Investigation

The sensationalized coverage fueled a “morbid fascination” with Short’s death among the public, he adds. “New theories and rumors were emerging daily in Los Angeles.” 

Police have investigated numerous suspects over the years, including Margolis, who was a 21-year-old World War II veteran studying pre-medicine at the University of Southern California at the time of Short’s murder. 

Margolis briefly lived with Short three months before her murder, but he didn’t admit that to investigators right away. After being questioned in connection with the crime, he moved to Chicago and changed his name to Marvin Merrill, then to Marty Merrill. He died of cancer in July 1993 at the age of 68. 

Cold Case Files Classic

Cold Case Files Classic explores the 1% of cold cases that are solved.

Can the Black Dahlia Murder Ever Be Solved?

It’s now been nearly 80 years since Short was murdered. Given the amount of time that has elapsed, it’s “unlikely” the case will be solved at this point, according to Hale.   

“If she were still alive, Elizabeth Short would turn 102 in July,” he says. “This means that any of her contemporaries, or even witnesses, would likely be 95 years old or older at this point. Anyone with a memory of the events is likely very old or deceased.”

However, Dr. Leslie Dobson, a clinical and forensic psychologist, is more optimistic. She points to recent technological advances that have helped solve numerous decades-old cold cases—but, she says, those tools alone won’t be enough to solve the Black Dahlia case.

“Frankly, someone needs to spill the tea,” she tells A&E Crime + Investigation. “Deathbed confessions, family members coming forward, a journal found in an attic or under a bed ... Secrets have a way of outliving the people who keep them.”

The killer is likely dead at this point, which means there would be no prosecution, no punishment and no justice. However, she notes, solving the case would still provide closure for Short’s family members, the countless investigators who have worked on the case over the last eight decades and members of the public. 

No matter what happens, Dobson hopes Short will eventually be remembered as a person and a victim, rather than as a legendary character.

“What often gets lost,” she says, “is that Elizabeth Short was a 22-year-old woman who was brutally murdered. The case attracted a carnival of false confessors, media exploitation and amateur theorizing that, in many ways, buried her as a person under the legend of ‘the Black Dahlia.’ If there’s one thing solving this case could do beyond justice, it’s restoring her humanity.”

Unknown Burned Body AKA "Lavender Doe" Identified After 12 years - Cold Case Files (#2169)

Show: Cold Case Files: Dead West

A shocking murder, a nameless victim, and a 13-year search for the truth. Watch the story unfold in this clip from Season 1, Episode 6.

9:25m watch

Related Features:

Could Ted Bundy Be Responsible for 4 Cold Cases in Utah? New DNA May Hold the Key

In 2026, DNA connected Bundy to the 1974 murder of teen Laura Ann Aime.

6m read

Will New DNA Confirm Jack the Ripper’s Identity?

Although multiple suspects have been named, no one was convicted.

8m read

Did Ted Bundy Carry Out the 1969 Garden State Parkway Murders?

Teen Susan Davis and Elizabeth Perry were killed outside Ocean City, N.J.

7m read

Rosie Tapia’s Parents Are Still Searching for Their 6-Year-Old's Killer After More Than 30 Years

Authorities think someone living near the Salt Lake City home from which the 6-year-old was taken in 1995 may have more information.

7m read

Who Was the Atlanta Ripper?

An unidentified serial killer preyed on Black women during the 1910s.

5m read

Why Sam Sheppard—Who Inspired 'The Fugitive'—Had His Conviction Overturned

Sheppard was tried twice for the murder of his wife.

8m read

Could New DNA Analysis Break Open the Madeleine McCann Case?

The 3-year-old vanished from her family's vacation home in Portugal in 2007.

7m read

What Happened to Brenda Lambert? The West Virginia Mom Vanished After Her Son's Birthday Party

Brenda accused her husband of domestic violence before she vanished.

6m read

A Millionaire’s Wife Was Accused of His Murder, Along with Her Alleged Lover—Her Nephew

Candy Mossler and her nephew-turned-alleged-lover went on trial.

7m read

Who Is the Angel of the Meadow? The U.K. Jane Doe Mystery

She has lain unidentified in a cemetery since 2010.

6m read

Brazil’s World Cup Trophy Was Stolen in 1983 and Has Never Been Found

Brazil got to keep the Jules Rimet Trophy after three World Cup wins.

5m read

What Happened to 7-Year-Old Kyron Horman, Who Never Returned from School in 2010?

The boy disappeared after attending his school science fair on June 4, 2010.

7m read

The Nancy Guthrie Case: A Timeline

The mom of 'Today' show's Savannah Guthrie vanished February 1, 2026.

10m read

The Search for the Santa Rosa Hitchhiker Murderer Continues More Than 5 Decades Later

Seven girls and young women were murdered in California in the 1970s.

5m read

The Wonderland Murders: Inside the Brutal Crime that Inspired Hollywood

Four people were killed in the July 1, 1981, attack.

6m read

What Happened to Bonnie Lee Schultz, Who Disappeared on July 4, 1997?

The Indiana mom had previously discussed divorce with her husband Rick.

7m read

The Unsolved Missing Person Case Linked to Bigfoot

Theresa Bier went to find Bigfoot in the California mountains.

7m read

Who Killed Fitness Influencer Missy Bevers?

The exercise instructor was murdered inside a Texas church in 2016.

6m read

Ashley Summers Went Missing in 2007 at Age 14—Was She Abducted?

Family members last saw the teenager in Cleveland on July 9, 2007.

5m read

Who Killed a Louisiana Fire Chief’s Wife in 2017?

Nanette Krentel suffered a gunshot wound to the back of her head at the burned-out home she shared with her fire chief husband.

7m read

Grace Brown Thought She Was Getting Engaged on a 1906 Lake Trip—Instead She Got Murdered

Chester Gillette was convicted of Brown's killing and executed.

6m read

Who Killed TV Star Bob Crane?

The 'Hogan's Heroes' actor was murdered in Scottsdale, Ariz., in June 1978.

7m read

When Her Dad Didn’t Come Home from Work in 1987, Kate Crane Went Looking for Answers

Bullet holes and blood were found in Eddy Crane's office after he vanished.

11m read

Who Killed Mom of 2 Stephanie Wasilishin?

“The first thing she said to me in the back of the cop car is, ‘Papi killed mommy! Papi killed mommy!’”

6m read

Is Alissa Turney’s Adoptive Dad Responsible for the Teen’s Disappearance, or Did She Run Away?

Michael Turney was acquitted, but Alissa’s sister seeks answers.

7m read

Did Witchcraft Play a Role in a 16-Year-Old's 1972 Killing?

Jeannette Christine DePalma disappeared in New Jersey in August 1972.

6m read

How Racial Disparities May Have Impacted the 'Freeway Phantom' Case

Six Black girls were killed in the D.C. area during the early 1970s.

6m read

Can a Check Fraud Case Help Solve 12-Year-Old Kade Lewin’s Murder?

The seventh grader was shot and killed in Brooklyn, N.Y., on March 31, 2022.

5m read

How a Chance Encounter—and a DNA Sample—Helped Find a Missing College Student After 51 Years

Douglas Brick disappeared in 1973, and the manner of his death remains unknown.

7m read

When the Flint River Killer’s Daughter Was Murdered, His DNA Helped Break the Case

Carl Patton's daughter Melissa Wolfenbarger was murdered in 1999.

8m read

A 10-Year-Old Left for School on a Snow Day in 2005 and Never Returned

A group of kids came across Adre’anna Jackson's remains in April 2006.

7m read

Kristin Smart’s Killer Was Convicted, But the Search for Her Body Continues

Paul Flores was found guilty of the college student's 1996 murder.

6m read

Jacob Olivier's Mom Hopes to Find Son Who Went Missing in the Everglades

The 23-year-old trekked from Texas to Florida in 2011.

5m read

Could the Oakland County Child Killings Be Solved After 50 Years?

Four children were murdered in Michigan between 1976 and 1977.

6m read

A Mom Interrupted a Burglary on St. Patrick's Day 1981—Her Killer Remains Unknown

Marlene Hayes came home sick to someone burglarizing her Maryland home.

5m read

A New York Heiress Disappeared in 1910. More Than a Century Later, She Is Still Missing

Dorothy Arnold vanished in Manhattan over 115 years ago.

7m read

Shot After Her Big Break: The Unsolved Murder of TV’s Barbara Colby

Colby's character was murdered in a TV show before she died in real life.

6m read

What Happened to Brian Shaffer? Med Student Disappeared from Ohio Bar

The Ohio State medical student has not been seen since April 1, 2006.

7m read

Can True Crime Media Help Victims—and Solve Cases?

A true crime documentary or podcast can often go beyond entertainment.

6m read

Nick Yarris Spent 21 Years Behind Bars for a Crime He Didn’t Commit—Now His Story Is on Broadway

Yarris brings his story to the Great White Way with 'The Fear of 13'.

6m read

A Single Mom Was Captured from a Hospital Parking Lot After Receiving Calls from a Stalker

An unidentified caller tormented Dorothy Jane Scott for months.

6m read

Will Hair Found On Amy Mihaljevic’s Clothes Lead to a Conviction After 36 Years?

DNA advances have lead to renewed hope in the 10-year-old's case.

6m read

10 Years After the Skelton Brothers Went Missing, Their Dad, John Skelton, Was Charged with Murder

Andrew, Alexander and Tanner Skelton were declared legally dead.

7m read

A Man Killed the Mother of His Unborn Baby. Her Body Has Never Been Found

Akia Eggleston did not show up to her own baby shower in 2017.

7m read

The Wild West Deep Creek Murders That Remain Unsolved After 130 Years

Daniel Cummings and John Wilson were killed in February 1896.

7m read

Are the Zodiac Killer and the Black Dahlia's Killer the Same Person?

A self-taught codebreaker believes he’s solved two of the most vexing cold cases of the 20th century.

8m read

A Serial Killer Known As 'The Doodler' Is Likely Still At Large

Victims are still waiting for the Bay Area killer to be apprehended.

6m read

Nearly 4 Decades Later, Venus Xtravaganza’s Murder Still Haunts the LGTBQ+ Community

The transgender woman stood out in the documentary 'Paris Is Burning'.

6m read

How Did Katarzyna Zowada Die? The College Student's Corpse Was Skinned

The college student’s remains were found in the Vistula River in 1999.

7m read

When Does an Investigation Become a Cold Case?

JonBenét Ramsey and Madeleine McMann's cases both fall into that category.

6m read

A Psychic Claims She Knows Who Killed Long-Missing Dad George Carroll, Found Buried Beneath His Home

Dorothy Carroll didn't file a missing person’s report for him.

5m read

After 40 Years, Can Dian Fossey’s Murder Be Solved?

The zoologist was 53 years old when she was slaughtered in 1985.

5m read

The 1990 Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum Robbery Is Still the Biggest Unsolved Art Heist in the U.S.

Two thieves left the Boston museum with 13 masterpieces in 1990.

7m read

The 5 Cold Cases True Crime Influencer Mike Brieaddy Most Wants to See Solved

His Making a True Crimerer channels cover unsolved mysteries.

8m read

New DNA Testing Techniques Might Lead to Answers in Susan Poupart’s Disappearance After 35 Years

The body of the mother of two was found on Thanksgiving in 1990.

7m read

The Fatal Stabbing of Penn State Student Betsy Aardsma Remains Unsolved More Than 55 Years Later

The grad student was fatally stabbed in a university library.

7m read

The Death of Sandra Denise Thomas: A Small Town Tries to Crack a Cold Case

The body of the Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina woman was found in a ditch with injuries consistent with being thrown...

6m read

How a Group of Active and Retired Homicide Investigators Anonymously Solve Cold Cases

Retired investigator Joe Kennedy established a coalition of investigators who help police departments in the U.S. solve cold cases.

8m read

The Still Unsolved 1879 Atlanta Double Killing That Rattled the Nation

The DeFoors were found hacked to death in their Georgia home.

6m read

A Reporter's Role in the Oldest Prosecution of a Serial Killer in U.S. History and Covering Civil Rights Era Murders

A&E speaks with journalist Jerry Mitchell about his book and how to handle cold cases.

8m read

The Delphi Murders: Why Police Have Not Released Details on the Murders of Libby German and Abby Williams

Since the 2017 murder of Indiana teens Libby German and Abby Williams, local authorities have not released any information about the cause or time of death of either victim, leading to rumors and speculation. We spoke with Indiana State Police First Sgt. Jerry Holeman about why the police are holding back details about the murder.

6m read

Who Murdered Sophie Toscan du Plantier? Producer's Mysterious Death Remains Unsolved

The French producer's murder in West Cork shocked the normally crime-free region of Ireland.

6m read

Who Was Jack the Stripper, Serial Killer of London in the 1960s?

In the 1960s, an unidentified serial killer terrorized London sex workers.

5m read

Are the Smiley Face Killers Real?

Nearly 20 years ago, retired NYPD detectives started tracking the suspicious drownings of young men across the country.

6m read

The Lane Bryant Shootings: Chicago Mass Murder Still Unsolved More Than 10 Years Later

On February 2, 2008, a man walked into a woman's clothing store in Chicago and shot and killed five women. It's one of the worst mass murders in the city's history, and the murderer is still on the loose.

7m read

The Tylenol Murders: Is It Too Late to Solve the Famous Cold Case?

On September 29, 1982, and in the few days that followed, seven people in the Chicago area died in Tylenol-related poisonings. The capsules were all laced with cyanide. The killer or killers have never been found.

8m read

Nadia Malik's Mysterious Death Still Unsolved

A Pennsylvania woman was found dead in her car in 2014 after getting into an argument with her boyfriend. The cause of her death is unknown.

10m read

The Unsolved Rainbow Murders: What Happened to Vicki Durian and Nancy Santomero?

The double murder of hitchhikers Vicki Durian and Nancy Santomero in the summer of 1980 shook Pocahontas County, West Virginia. Nearly 40 years later, the Appalachian community is still haunted by the unsolved case, now known as the 'Rainbow Murders.'

6m read

What Happened to Hannah Upp? The Mystery Around the Young Woman's Disappearance Continues

The mysterious multiple disappearances of Hannah Upp have been a public fascination for years—but are we any closer to finding answers?

6m read

The Mysterious Unsolved Murders of Sisters Barbara and Patricia Grimes

On December 28, 1956, the Grimes sisters, 15 and 12, left home to watch heartthrob Elvis Presley in Love Me Tender in Chicago. Six decades later, their inexplicable murder remains unsolved.

7m read

The Black Dahlia: How 'Moral Panic' Gripped the Community in the Wake of Elizabeth Short's Gruesome Murder

After the still-unsolved murder of Elizabeth Short—the 22-year-old woman and aspiring starlet later dubbed 'The Black Dahlia'— the media and preachers used the case to warn young women of what could happen when you try to leave your family and seek fame.

6m read

Will the West Mesa Serial Killer Ever Be Identified?

In the 2000s, the New Mexico desert became a graveyard for 11 females and an unborn child—their lives taken by a serial killer who became known as The West Mesa Bone Collector.

6m read

About the author

Sarah Kuta

Sarah Kuta is a writer and editor based in Colorado. Her work has appeared in Smithsonian Magazine, NBC News, Conde Nast Traveler, Robb Report, Food & Wine, Lonely Planet, the Denver Post, 5280 Magazine, the Toronto Star, and many other publications.

More by Author

Fact Check

We strive for accuracy and fairness. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! A&E reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it is complete and accurate.

Citation Information

Article Title
Can Fingerprints from 1943 Solve the Black Dahlia Murder?
Website Name
A&E
Date Accessed
August 12, 2026
Publisher
A&E Television Networks
Last Updated
August 12, 2026
Original Published Date
August 12, 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement