Crime + investigation
How a Teen Detective Helped Solve a 9-Year-Old’s Murder After 58 Years
Marise Chiverella left early for school to give her teacher a present in March 1964 and never came back.
Marise Chiverella always walked to St. Joseph’s Parochial School with her siblings.
But on March 18, 1964, the 9-year-old was excited about giving her teacher a present and left early, on her own.
Marise’s body was found that afternoon, bound and gagged in a coal mining area in Hazel Township, Penn. The little girl had been sexually assaulted and beaten, officials said, per a season 4 episode of A&E’s Cold Case Files.
Despite the best efforts of police, it took 58 years until advanced DNA technology and genealogical sleuthing identified Marise’s murderer.
“We always felt it would be solved,” Marise’s brother, Ronald Chiverella, tells A&E Crime + Investigation. “It was always about justice and wanting to find the individual who killed her— and to stop them from repeating what they did to Marise.”
Cold Case Files
Cold Case Files explores the 1% of cold cases that are solved.
‘She Was Reborn’
Marise grew up in Hazleton, a coal town in the foothills of the Pocono Mountains.
At home, Marise loved pulling pranks, building snowhouses and playing Bingo with her siblings. But at school, she was much quieter because of a speech impediment, Chiverella says.
That changed in second grade, when a speech teacher helped Marise overcome her difficulties. “From then on, her shyness and being introverted all changed. She was reborn, full of energy,” he says.
The youngster also had a deeply spiritual side, sharing her mother’s strong faith, and dreaming of becoming a nun. On March 18, 1964, Marise hurried to school, planning to surprise her teacher—a nun—before Mass started with a gift of canned fruit for her feast day.
‘No Real Suspects’
Chiverella remembers leaving high school when a car drove up and the parish priest got out. “He put his hand on my shoulder and said, ‘Ronald, your sister, Marise, is dead. Go home, your mother needs you,’” he recounts.
Overwhelmed, the teenager ran home to find the house full of shocked and grieving relatives.
"My mother was heart-struck and in shock,” Chiverella remembers. His father was stoic but broke down when he visited the crime scene.
Pennsylvania State Police launched a manhunt, combed the area and interviewed hundreds of residents in vain.
“We have nobody in custody and no real suspects,” Pennsylvania State Police Lt. Edward Switaj told reporters after Marise’s funeral.
Marise’s mother, Mary Chiverella, kept hoping for justice. At Sunday dinners when the family gathered, she’d pray, “Jesus, please help the Pennsylvania State Police find the person who hurt Marise,’” her son remembers.
Before Mary died in 2014, she told her children, “I forgive the person who hurt Marise.”
“That’s the type of woman she was. Myself, I’m not there yet,” Chiverella, who couldn’t bear to talk about the tragedy for years, says. “I was still stuck in the horror of that day.”
An Unexpected Ally
Pennsylvania State Police continued to revisit the murder, trying out new crime-solving technology methods, including DNA testing in the 1990s to identify seminal fluid on Marise’s clothing.
Those early attempts yielded nothing, but in 2007, advances in DNA science generated a profile of the killer. It was sent to the FBI’s Combined DNA Index System with no results.
Pennsylvania State Police Sgt. Mark Baron took on the cold case a decade later.
“They say you can’t let emotions get in the way,” he tells A&E Crime + Investigation. “I couldn’t help not getting emotionally attached.”
In 2018, investigators worked with a tech lab that uploaded the DNA profile to a genealogical database. A match was found with a distant relative, but “the chances that they could a identify suspect, were very, very minute,” Baron says.
Help came in 2020 from an unorthodox source: genealogical researcher and college student Eric Schubert. The 18-year-old had helped other police departments solve cold cases, and he offered his services for free.
Given Schubert’s age, “I thought, this has to be a joke,” Baron recalls. They met, however, and Schubert “was very professional. We walked away thinking, ‘This kid’s the real deal.’”
Schubert joined the investigative team and worked up complex family trees for police.
“Marise deserved justice, and her family deserved to know who was responsible,” Schubert tells A&E Crime + Investigation, adding, “there were very few close genetic relatives to work with, which made the case especially challenging.”
The Man Who Killed a 9-Year-Old at a Church Confessed Decades Later
Investigators linked William Schrader to the 1962 murder of Carol Ann Dougherty.
Investigators linked William Schrader to the 1962 murder of Carol Ann Dougherty.
Narrowing Down the Suspects
In the ensuing months, investigators uploaded the profile to a different genealogical database, which yielded more results, Baron recounts. Police found one relative—a family historian—who provided the team with additional names.
“We kept following the evidence and eliminating probabilities,” Schubert explains.
Baron and his partner, Trooper James Quiroz, spent hours researching and tracking down people genetically linked to the killer.
Surprisingly, when two cops knocked on the door and asked for a DNA sample, “nobody slammed the door in our faces,” Baron recalls.
The investigators did everything from watching morning TV with strangers to chatting about Elvis to gain people’s trust. Their technique worked so well they even convinced one man with a criminal past to provide a DNA sample, which was a close match to the suspect’s DNA.
By late 2021, investigators had slimmed the possibilities down to two brothers.
“We obtained DNA from one brother’s widow and it excluded him paternally. With that, we knew it was one person, and that one person was James Forte,” Baron remembers.
Who Was James Paul Forte?
James Paul Forte lived about seven blocks from the Chiverellas and was 22 when he kidnapped Marise, authorities said.
Later in 1974, he pleaded guilty to aggravated assault after sexually assaulting a woman in a coal mine. In 1978, Forte was charged with recklessly endangering another person and harassment, authorities said, but they did not have more info on the case’s outcome.
He was working as a bartender in Hazleton when he died of a heart attack in 1980 at age 38.
Because the 1978 crime “is so similar to the murder,” criminologist Stephen Jones tells A&E Crime + Investigation, “I would be very surprised if there weren’t a couple more assaults that weren’t tied to him.”
Such a vicious attack on a child indicates that “realistically, he’s trending toward serial sexual sadist,” says Jones, Willistown Township Police Department detective sergeant and adjunct professor at Rosemont College in Pennsylvania.
Answers, Not Closure
Forte’s remains were exhumed on January 6, 2022, and DNA testing confirmed he was Marise’s killer on February 3.
Baron updated Chiverella, who immediately called his siblings.
As the family talked, “Spanish Eyes” played in the background on his younger brother’s radio. The song had been their parents’ favorite waltz. “It was a sign,” Chiverella believes.
State police announced the case was solved at a news conference on February 10, 2022.
“Just knowing that the killer isn’t still at large and wasn’t someone we knew is a release,” Chiverella says.
But, “it doesn’t change 60 years of not having Marise,” he admits. “I don’t have the nieces and nephews I could have lived with. I don’t have closure, I have answers.”
A Mother and Her 2 Children Vanish Suddenly
Show: American JusticeA mother and her two children suddenly and suspiciously vanish, in this clip from Season 15, Episode 12.
Related Features:
Child Serial Killer Joseph Kondro Victim’s Family Says There’s ‘No Justice’ Decades Later: ‘It’s Horrific’
The father of six was convicted of the sexual assaults and murders of two girls.
How an 11-Year-Old Survived a 3-Year Abduction Following a Custody Dispute
Andrew Escobar's mom took her son away after losing custody to the boy's dad.
Did a Babysitter Who Locked Twins in a Refrigerator Do the Same Thing to a Toddler on Halloween?
Nima Louise Carter was taken from her crib and killed in 1977.
An 11-Year-Old Girl Went Missing After a Girl Scouts Halloween Party—It Took 20 Years for Her Killer to Be Revealed
Two brothers targeted her one night in Oil City, Penn., in 1992.
About the author
Fact Check
We strive for accuracy and fairness. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! A&E reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it is complete and accurate.
Citation Information
- Article Title
- How a Teen Detective Helped Solve a 9-Year-Old’s Murder After 58 Years
- Author
- C.M. Frankie
- Website Name
- A&E
- Date Accessed
- November 19, 2026
- Publisher
- A&E Television Networks
- Last Updated
- November 19, 2026
- Original Published Date
- November 19, 2026