Crime + investigation
Who Killed Liz Barraza? Inside the 2019 Garage Sale Murder Case
She was raising funds for a wedding anniversary trip when she was gunned down in her driveway.
In the early morning hours of January 25, 2019, a black mid-size truck drove past Elizabeth “Liz” Barraza’s home in Texas and came to a stop. A person who appeared to have long hair got out of the truck and walked up to Liz, who was standing in the driveway, setting up a garage sale.
Liz had taken the day off from her job as a data reporter for a pipeline inspection company to raise some extra money for a fifth wedding anniversary trip to Universal Studios Florida and Disney World.
She said “good morning” to the car's driver, lead investigator Sgt. Michael Ritchie of the Harris County Sheriff’s Office told ABC13. Then, four shots were fired. The driver fled.
“The day before, we were just watching Netflix and chilling on a couch, and then the next day, I'm having to go see her at the hospital,” Sergio Barraza, Liz’s husband, tells A&E Crime + Investigation. “It's insane, you know?"
Three neighbors called 911. At 1:40 p.m. the next day, Liz was pronounced dead.
She donated her heart, liver, corneas and kidneys, according to a website set up by her parents, Rosemary and Bob Nuelle.
Accused: Guilty or Innocent?
Follows people facing trial for serious crimes they are alleged to have committed.
Who Killed Liz Barraza?
The Harris County Sheriff’s Office, Texas Rangers and FBI collectively worked on Liz’s case. No one has yet been charged with her murder.
Ritchie says the suspect likely knew where Liz lived and waited for her husband to leave home, being familiar with the white work van he would be driving. They also used a revolver, which didn’t leave behind casings.
“I believe they had to know that she would be outside, alone and exposed,” he adds. “If she was going to work that day, they would’ve been too late.”
Everybody's a suspect in Ritchie’s book, including Sergio and Liz’s father-in-law, Oscar Barraza, though Ritchie also tells A&E Crime + Investigation, “Sergio Barraza has been 100% cooperative. I've not found anything that would incriminate him at this time.”
However, from what Ritchie has read and seen in his 11 years of investigating homicides, when a woman is murdered, it is usually by someone she knows—and it’s usually her current or former significant other.
“I completely am understanding of the detective's position, and I appreciate that he's not writing people off just because he can't find sufficient evidence,” Sergio says. “I will always be an open book towards him because I really want to figure this out, because she deserves it, honestly.”
The motive for this crime is unclear. One theory explored in an episode of the docuseries Somebody Knows Something asks if Liz was targeted for a $500,000 life insurance policy she had taken out. Sergio says he has not touched the money and doesn’t plan to until there is some kind of resolution with Liz’s case.
“I honestly didn't even know it existed until her dad told me about it,” Sergio says. They stumbled upon the insurance when they were handling the paperwork that comes after somebody dies, he adds.
Around the time of Liz’s murder, Sergio’s most recent check from working with his father, Oscar, bounced, and she was troubled by it, Ritchie said to ABC13. “My father had been having money issues,” Sergio says. “We didn't know it at the time, but he had been seeing multiple women and giving out money.”
The couple had talked about confronting Oscar, so it is possible that Liz spoke with Oscar herself and he may have wanted her “out of the picture,” though this is circumstantial, Ritchie added.
Oscar was not honest with authorities, but that may be attributable to affairs he was allegedly having, Ritchie tells A&E Crime + Investigation. He also passed a polygraph test.
Oscar did not respond to A&E Crime + Investigation’s request for comment.
Ritchie says authorities have evidence from the crime scene that they did not have the technology to process at the time of the murder. “Now that is actually in the works,” he says. His office is hoping to have results back in late 2026 or early 2027.
Ritchie declined to share the nature of the evidence, saying he believes that if someone knows who killed Liz, they’ll know about this evidence as well. “Many, many, many, many people have called in saying, 'I think it's this person,' but not one has ever mentioned this evidence and so that’s why I have to keep it confidential,” he says. He is waiting for a person with knowledge of both to come forward.
Who Shot Takeoff? Murder Trial Pushed to 2027 as New Evidence Examined
Patrick Xavier Clark will stand trial in April 2027 for murdering the Migos rapper.
Patrick Xavier Clark will stand trial in April 2027 for murdering the Migos rapper.
In the Public Interest
This case is different from other homicides Ritchie has investigated.
Liz was on her property, conducting a garage sale, in a fairly safe neighborhood. “Liz could’ve been anybody’s wife, anybody’s sister, anybody's daughter, anybody’s friend,” he says. “And I think a lot of people think, ‘Man, if this happened to her, this could happen to me.’”
Seven years later, her case remains open as family and supporters search for answers. “Liz’s parents did a great job of keeping this case in the forefront and keeping it in the media,” Ritchie says.
Ritchie also says the Harris County Sheriff’s Office gets Crime Stoppers tips regarding this case all the time. Crime Stoppers of Houston has a page for Liz’s case where it lists an up to $50,000 reward for information that leads to the charge and/or arrest of a suspect.
The reward money was raised from $20,000 to $50,000 in 2022 with the help of over 145 donors, many of them strangers. Star Wars fans also raised funds for the reward. (Liz and Sergio were part of a charity group called the 501st Legion, which recreates Star Wars villains' costumes.) Sergio says part of the money also came from Peter Mayhew, who played Chewbacca in the movies.
“[Liz] was a strong, happy, loving and caring young woman who was taken from us far too soon,” Bob said at a press conference.
In May 2026, he died from cancer.
“I want to keep [Liz’s] story alive so that she doesn't get lost,” Sergio says.
Defense Attorney Found Murdered in Her Office
Show: American JusticeWhen an up-and-coming defense attorney is murdered in her office, her colleagues vow to seek justice.
Related Features:
11-Year-Old Madalina Cojocari Vanished in 2022 After Mom Engaged in Witchcraft Activity
A school employee reported the girl missing three weeks after she was last seen.
Did a Fire Destroy Critical Evidence in the Murders of a Mom and Her Daughter?
Heather and Kira Radcliffe's December 2006 murders remain unsolved.
An Anesthesiologist Accused of Assault Fled and Evaded Capture for 21 Years
Ronald L. Fischer ran away while on trial for sexual assault in 2005.
Who Shot Takeoff? Murder Trial Pushed to 2027 as New Evidence Examined
Patrick Xavier Clark will stand trial in April 2027 for murdering the Migos rapper.
About the author
Sanjana Bhambhani
Sanjana Bhambhani is a New York-based journalist and documentarian whose work appears on the BBC, The Rachel Maddow Show and New York Focus among other outlets. She covers a spectrum of subjects including police misconduct, the justice system, space science and women's history.
Fact Check
We strive for accuracy and fairness. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! A&E reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it is complete and accurate.
Citation Information
- Article Title
- Who Killed Liz Barraza? Inside the 2019 Garage Sale Murder Case
- Author
- Sanjana Bhambhani
- Website Name
- A&E
- Date Accessed
- November 19, 2026
- Publisher
- A&E Television Networks
- Last Updated
- November 19, 2026
- Original Published Date
- November 19, 2026