Crime + investigation

How 9-Year-Old Jessica Lunsford’s Murder Led to Stricter Laws for Sexual Offenders

John Evander Couey was a convicted sex offender at the time he abducted and killed the Florida girl in February 2005.

Getty Images
Published: January 13, 2026Last Updated: January 13, 2026

On the morning of February 24, 2005, Mark Lunsford expected to find his 9-year-old daughter asleep in her bed. But when he walked into her room, he made a startling realization: Jessica Lunsford was gone.

Mark was sure his daughter had not run away but, rather, had been abducted from the home they shared with his parents in Homosassa, Fla., a small town roughly 75 miles north of Tampa.

Police launched a massive search in hopes of finding Jessica alive and bringing her home safely. However, on March 19, 2005, investigators discovered her body in a shallow grave behind a nearby mobile home where 46-year-old sex offender John Evander Couey had been living with his half-sister.

The evidence later revealed Couey had sexually assaulted Jessica, then buried her alive inside two trash bags. Investigators say she poked her fingers through the plastic, as if trying to get out, before ultimately suffocating to death. Her body was found with a stuffed dolphin clutched in her arms.

Two years later, in March 2007, Couey was convicted of first-degree murder, burglary, kidnapping and sexual battery. He was sentenced to death by lethal injection, but died of natural causes in September 2009 before the execution could take place.

“[Couey] said one time that when he gets to heaven that he was gonna tell Jessie he is sorry,” Mark said at Couey’s sentencing hearing in August 2007, according to CNN. “I got bad news, I don't think you're gonna make it there.”

Crime in Progress

"Crime in Progress" follows the evolution of investigations in real time, told exclusively through raw body cam, dash cam and surveillance footage.

Advocating for Other Children

Mark was devastated by his daughter’s death. But he was also angry—angry at a system that had allowed Couey to slip through the cracks.

In 1991, Couey had been convicted of exposing and fondling himself in front of a 5-year-old girl, telling police he had touched other children in the past. He was sentenced to five years in prison but was released on parole after two years. Despite the requirements of his conviction, Couey had failed to register with authorities when he moved in with his half-sister, which meant the Lunsfords had no idea a sex offender was living nearby.  

“The problem is still growing,” Mark said at Couey’s sentencing, according to CNN. “Children are still being molested. Sex offenders and predators are still being released. Justice was served for this little girl, but what about the rest of them? What about the ones that survive? You can't do anything to bring my daughter back, but you can do everything to save these other kids.”

Mark made it his mission to ensure other children would not suffer the same way Jessica had. He lobbied for tougher sex offender laws across the nation, including in his home state of Florida, which in 2005 enacted the Jessica Lunsford Act, also known as Jessica’s Law. 

The Florida statute mandates stricter registration requirements and harsher penalties for sex offenders, such as electronic monitoring for certain individuals, a 25-year minimum prison sentence for incidents involving children under 12, and twice-yearly, in-person check-ins at the local sheriff’s office. 

Dozens of other states followed suit, passing similar laws that cracked down on sex offenders and improved tracking. 

Changes to the Law

It’s not surprising that Jessica’s death led to legislative changes, Colleen M. Berryessa, an associate professor at the Rutgers-Newark School of Criminal Justice, tells A&E Crime + Investigation. Her murder is an example of a seminal event—a high-profile crime that drew intense media coverage and widespread public outrage. 

“This put pressure on legislators to quickly enact legislation that was perceived to prevent sexual victimization and achieve ‘justice,’” she says.

Yet experts believe these types of laws are largely ineffective—and may even be making the problem worse. 

“Basically, it’s legislation that makes us feel better and safer but, in reality, there’s no evidence to really support that,” Elizabeth Jeglic, a clinical psychologist at John Jay College of Criminal Justice and CUNY Graduate School who studies sexual violence prevention, sexual abuse and sexual grooming, tells A&E Crime + Investigation

Jeglic notes that research shows such laws often destabilize people convicted of sex offenses. 

“When [perpetrators] come back into the community, they can’t find work, they’re ostracized,” she adds. “By not giving them the things they need to reacclimatize, it can actually put them at increased risk for reoffending.”

Additionally, Jeglic points out that most sexual abuses are committed by someone the victim already knows—just 31% are committed by strangers, according to the nonprofit Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network (RAINN). Legislation based on “stranger danger,” she says, serves as a distraction from the true problem.

“It doesn’t feel good to us to think people in our child’s surroundings could be the ones who are hurting them, but that’s the reality,” she says. “[These incidents] go undisclosed and undetected because we’re still telling kids, ‘Don’t take candy from strangers,’ and, ‘If somebody stops you, run away.’ But we don’t talk about what to do when it’s your friend, your uncle, your teacher at school. Those are the kinds of things we want to be talking about more.”

Berryessa echoes this, adding that legislation like Jessica’s Law is expensive to implement—and that those funds could be better spent on programs that address the root causes of sexual abuse and reduce recidivism.

The public, Berryessa says, is largely unaware that these policies fail to achieve their intended goals. But even when people are aware, research suggests many still want the statutes to remain in place.

“By keeping laws on the books that do not address the core issues that lead to and do little to prevent sexual offending, we put ourselves in a position to see the same issues and levels of victimization continue in society moving forward,” Berryessa says.

Jessica Lunsford’s Legacy Lives On

Beyond the legislative changes, Jessica’s memory endures in other ways, too. Homosassa Elementary School installed a playground in her memory, and the Citrus County Children’s Advocacy Center was renamed in her honor. Staff and volunteers at “Jessie’s Place” continue to work tirelessly to protect local children from violence, abuse and neglect. 

It’s now been 20 years since Jessica was murdered, but to her family, it feels like the brutal crime took place yesterday.

“Grief lasts forever,” Mark told the Citrus County Chronicle in February 2025. “... Those pains never go away… Grief is like an open wound, and when you’re reminded of it, then it reopens and it hurts all over again.”

Beyond the Headlines: The Abduction of Abby Hernandez

Abby Hernandez recounts her terrifying abduction and months in captivity revealing the twisted mind games and manipulation she endured.

10:11m watch

About the author

Sarah Kuta

Sarah Kuta is a writer and editor based in Colorado. Her work has appeared in Smithsonian Magazine, NBC News, Conde Nast Traveler, Robb Report, Food & Wine, Lonely Planet, the Denver Post, 5280 Magazine, the Toronto Star, and many other publications.

More by Author

Fact Check

We strive for accuracy and fairness. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! A&E reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it is complete and accurate.

Citation Information

Article Title
How 9-Year-Old Jessica Lunsford’s Murder Led to Stricter Laws for Sexual Offenders
Website Name
A&E
Date Accessed
January 13, 2026
Publisher
A&E Television Networks
Last Updated
January 13, 2026
Original Published Date
January 13, 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement